Tuesday, May 13, 2014

Review - Cinder by Marissa Meyer

Title: Cinder
Series: The Lunar Chronicles #1
Author: Marissa Meyer
Published: January, 2012
Pages: 387
Goodreads Rating: 4.09 Stars
My Rating: 4.5/5 Stars
My Content Rating: YA (Nothing more than kissing, Some mild violence)

Summary from Goodreads: Humans and androids crowd the raucous streets of New Beijing. A deadly plague ravages the population. From space, a ruthless lunar people watch, waiting to make their move. No one knows that Earth’s fate hinges on one girl. 

Cinder, a gifted mechanic, is a cyborg. She’s a second-class citizen with a mysterious past, reviled by her stepmother and blamed for her stepsister’s illness. But when her life becomes intertwined with the handsome Prince Kai’s, she suddenly finds herself at the center of an intergalactic struggle, and a forbidden attraction. Caught between duty and freedom, loyalty and betrayal, she must uncover secrets about her past in order to protect her world’s future.


Cinder is an incredibly unique re-telling of Cinderella.  Set in a futuristic world that has been ravaged by a plague, Cinder is just trying to survive. When she meets Prince Kai, she knows that nothing can come of her attraction to him - after all, she's an android, barely tolerated by the world. But, she finds herself entangled in Prince Kai's ongoing struggle for power with the cold and calculating Queen Levania, and Cinder discovers that she can't hide from him anymore.

The negatives:
  • Villain isn't well-defined.  Queen Levania (the evil Lunar queen) isn't all that well-defined in this book.  We get glimpses of her, but we don't know anything about what motivates her (besides power), and she's relatively two-dimensional.  However, since this is a series, I'm hoping that we will get to see lots more of Queen Levania in future books and learn more about her.  Because of this, I would say that this is a minor negative.
  • Predictable twist.  I think just about anyone could have told you pretty early on what we were going to find out in the "twist."  It was pretty much blatantly spelled out for you.  Still, I enjoyed the characters' discovery of the truth, so I was okay with it.
What I loved:
  • The story.  I LOVED Meyer's take on the Cinderella fairy tale.  It is hard to imagine a Cinderella story involving androids and plagues, but Meyer makes it work.  She takes elements of the original fairy tale and weaves them into a fascinating and wholly original new story.  If you're at all a fan of re-tellings and you haven't read this one yet, you should definitely pick it up!
  • Cinder and Prince Kai.  I really connected to Cinder and her story.  I sympathized with her in her loneliness and her feelings of "otherness" since she was an android, and I could definitely understand why she felt that her attraction to Prince Kai was hopeless.  I felt her suffering when things went seriously wrong (which they definitely did) and couldn't help but hope for that fairy tale ending from the original story for her.  But, Cinder didn't sit around and feel sorry for herself - no, she was strong, smart and witty. Certainly not a boring Cinderella! Then there was Prince Kai. He was a fitting prince, struggling between his duty to his kingdom and his own happiness.  He tried so hard to do what was right, but there were never any clear answers for him, which I actually appreciated.  I was never quite sure what Prince Kai was going to do or how their story was going to end up!
I can't wait to read Scarlet and find out what happens next in this series. I give Cinder 4.5/5 stars.



Comments (19)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
So glad you liked it! I agree wholeheartedly with your analysis. I wished the villain was stronger, and that one plot twist was extremely predictable, but I still enjoyed reading it. I haven't read Scarlet or Cress yet, I'm waiting until Winter is released and then I'll read all three back-to-back, but I hear that the series improves with each book.
My recent post Top Ten Books I Almost Put Down But Didn't
1 reply · active 571 weeks ago
I'm debating waiting for Winter before I read further too, but I haven't decided yet. I am excited to keep reading this series, so I don't know if I can wait!
I thought this was was fantastic and I have yet to read Cress.
I might be the only one that hasn't figured out were she is taking this however someone mentioned it to me and I was like OHHHH duh!!! lol I guess I'm a little slow :)

Great review! can't wait to see what you think if Scarlet.
My recent post Author’s Spotlight – Yolanda Ashton
1 reply · active 571 weeks ago
Interesting - I can't wait to see what Meyer has in store for us with the rest of the series!
Nothing worse than the predictable twist. Sometimes I feel quite cool when I call it, but I think with something that has so much hype and so many people like, it is pretty pants that you called it! However, I am really glad you like the relationships and plot. I am still a bit reluctant to pick this up beause sc-fi is not my jam but I will muster up the courage soon! :')

Thanks for sharing & great review! :) xxx

Alex @ The Shelf Diaries
My recent post ARC Review: We Were Liars by E. Lockhart
I haven't read Cinder yet, but I think I will have to do it soon. It sounds like a great retelling. Although you had a couple of minor issues, it seems you enjoyed it! Fab review Nicole!

Naomi @ Nomi’s Paranormal Palace
My recent post Teaser Tuesday #91 – Torn from You by Nashoda Rose
This is one book/series that I was iffy about. It took me forever to actually give it a go. SO glad that I did. I absolutely love Cinder and I'm currently reading and loving Scarlet too. Cress, your next :)
Great Review. Thanks for sharing ♥
Book Hangovers
xoxo Michelle
My recent post Books That Almost Didn't Make It!!
1 reply · active 571 weeks ago
Yeah, I wasn't sure about this one either. I don't know exactly why - I think it was the cover. It just didn't appeal to me. But then, after hearing everyone rave about it, I decided I needed to give it a go. So glad I did!
I love love love this series. LOVE IT! This is hands down my favorite re-telling of fairy tales. LOVE IT! I am dying for the next book. I am so glad you liked it! I cannot wait for you to finish the other two. SO GOOD!!!!
My recent post CHILDRENS BOOK REVIEW - DISCOVER AMERICA - Beautiful Illustrations take Children Across America's Diverse Landscape
1 reply · active 570 weeks ago
I knew that just about everyone loved it - I don't know why it took me so long to catch up with everyone else!
YES. I love this book, I love this series! And don't worry--Queen Levania gets PLENTY evil ;) Also--again, agreed--Cinder is the most original retelling I've ever come across. LOVE it.
My recent post Review: Midnight Crossroad by Charlaine Harris
1 reply · active 570 weeks ago
Yes, it's quite amazing how Meyer manages to come up with this really unique setting and story and yet tie it into the original Cinderella storyline in so many ways!
Prince Kai and Cinder probably has the longest relationship that hasn't happened yet (does that make sense?). I'm really dying for these two to get together!

Glad you loved it, Nicole. I hope you'll love Scarlet! WOLF. WOLF. WOLF.
My recent post What I Thought Was True by Huntley Fitzpatrick
1 reply · active 570 weeks ago
Ha! So, I guess I shouldn't be expecting a HEA right away!
I loved this one and so am really glad you enjoyed it too. Having read all three books in the series so far and now thinking a bit on the point you made, I still feel like we don't completely know Queen Levania. Hopefully, Winter will change that!
My recent post Review: Dear Killer by Katherine Ewell
1 reply · active 570 weeks ago
Someone else mentioned that to me on Goodreads. I guess I just will have to be satisfied with the fact that Queen Levania is kind of a distant villain and we don't really get to know much about her and her motivations. I prefer villains who I understand a bit more, but that certainly won't stop me from reading (and enjoying) this series!
I absolutely LOVED this book! It is one of my favorites. Actually, the whole series is. Now I just need to read Winter!
My recent post Deadly Undertakings: A Review
I loved this twisted fairytale too. I have to get back into the series. Great review. Glad you liked it.
My recent post Review: Fragile Spirits by Mary Lindsey
1 reply · active 568 weeks ago
Yes, I need to get back to this series again soon. So many books to read!! :-)

Post a new comment

Comments by